Mortgage Myth #4: Your Tax Returns Don’t Show Enough Income

Michael Creed • August 4, 2025

Tax Returns Don’t Define You — Especially Not in Mortgage Lending

It happens all the time. A self-employed borrower walks into a bank, submits their tax returns, and walks out discouraged — denied for a mortgage because their net income “doesn’t qualify.”


Here’s the problem:  Net income isn’t always an accurate reflection of financial capacity — especially for business owners, freelancers, consultants, and investors.


That’s why we offer Non-QM mortgage options that tell the full financial story — not just what’s written on a tax form.


Understanding the Myth


Most conventional loans require full tax return documentation, W-2s, and predictable income streams. But if you write off expenses, earn 1099 income, or reinvest in your business, your taxable income might look artificially low.


That doesn’t mean you can’t qualify.


Real Solutions for Real Earners


Our Non-QM lending suite includes:

  • 1099-Only Loans: No tax returns. We use your gross income as reported on 1099s.
  • Bank Statement Loans: 12–24 months of personal or business deposits are averaged to calculate income.
  • Asset Depletion Loans: We convert your liquid or investment assets into a monthly income model.
  • DSCR Loans: For investment properties — we qualify based on rental cash flow, not your personal income.
  • P&L-Only and No-Ratio Options: For highly liquid borrowers with complex financials.


Who This Helps

  • Realtors, builders, consultants, and creatives
  • Gig economy professionals
  • Investors with multiple properties
  • Business owners with complex deductions
  • Retirees with high net worth but low income


Why This Myth Hurts Borrowers


Most banks and call centers are bound by rigid guidelines. If your paperwork doesn’t fit their mold, they stamp “declined” — and you’re left thinking you can’t buy.


That’s not the truth.


What We Do Differently


We underwrite what’s real. If you’ve been told “no” based on tax documents alone, we’ll show you how the right structure and loan type can turn that no into a yes.


Want to learn more about income-flexible mortgage solutions?


Contact me to (1) ask your questions and/or (2) to request our Non-QM Quick Guide.


Want to see other myths, check them out here.


Man signing a document at a table, with a woman and another person looking on; laptop visible.
By Michael Creed February 9, 2026
Married? You don’t always need both spouses on the mortgage. Learn when qualifying solo can improve approval odds and even lead to a better rate.
Family kneels in front of a house, wrapped in American flags, holding small flags.
By Michael Creed February 9, 2026
Many still believe VA loans are slow, strict, or one-time use. The truth? They’re among the most powerful and flexible loan programs available. Learn why.
Two hands exchanging a card that says
By Michael Creed February 2, 2026
Think you can’t use gift funds for your down payment? Think again. Learn how family gifts help first-time, move-up, and multigenerational buyers succeed.
Financial scene: toy house, coins, calculator, bank book, and documents on a desk.
By Michael Creed January 26, 2026
Student loans don’t disqualify you — lenders just calculate them differently. Learn how to qualify and turn debt into a doable homebuying plan.
Real estate agent gesturing to client, with model house on documents.
By Michael Creed January 19, 2026
Think bankruptcy disqualifies you from homeownership? It doesn’t. Learn the real waiting periods, what lenders look for, & how clients are buying again sooner than you think.
House covered in snow in southeast Wisconsin
By Michael Creed January 12, 2026
Think you can’t build in winter? In Wisconsin, you can—and it might be your best move. Learn how builders and lenders keep projects moving all year.
Realtor handing young couple keys to their first home.
By Michael Creed January 5, 2026
Think down payment assistance doesn’t exist? Truth: there are state, local, and national programs that can help buyers. Learn how they work here.
Family holding new keys to their home; they are all looking at the keys.
By Michael Creed December 29, 2025
Think you can’t buy a new home because of high DTI? Learn how bridge loans and buy-before-sell programs make it possible. Contact me for more details.
Feet with sock on them outside a moving box; having fun while moving.
By Michael Creed December 22, 2025
Think non-U.S. citizens can’t buy a home? That’s a myth. Many qualify with visas, green cards, or ITIN loans. Learn how you can serve these clients today.
Aerial view of open land with development potential
By Michael Creed December 15, 2025
Think you can’t finance land or mixed-use property? Wrong. The right mortgage strategy can make it possible. Learn how to unlock these opportunities.